"A radical and daring departure for McCaslin, and also a gesture that feels genuine and sweet, given Bowie's sudden, shocking death. But its claustrophobic rhythmic packets and opratic triumphalism are tiresome. And though McCaslin often plays with compelling lyricism, none of the tracks comes up to the level of "Dollar Days", on Blackstar itself ... Does that mean that McCaslin shouldn't have made this album? Absolutely not. There's real emotional clarity here. More jazz players should try crossing barriers like this, dipping into contemporary pop repertoire, whether they entirely succeed or not".